Dr Blake sets the record straight on police accountability and oversight

The Commissioner’s remarks came in the wake of recent promotions within the JCF, where 107 officers were elevated to the rank of Sergeant after completing the Sergeant Development Course. While congratulating the newly promoted officers, he reminded them that leadership within the JCF comes with heightened responsibility, particularly in supervising junior officers and upholding accountability. 

The Commissioner emphasized that accountability is deeply embedded in the JCF’s structure, beginning long before an officer is even confirmed. Recruits undergo extensive background checks, polygraph tests, and an eight-month training programme before entering a two-year probationary period. Even after confirmation, officers remain under strict supervision, with several structural mechanisms institutionalized. 

Beyond internal checks, the Commissioner highlighted multiple external agencies that hold the JCF accountable. 

The Commissioner acknowledged the role of civil society organizations such as Jamaicans for Justice (JFJ), Amnesty International, and Stand Up for Jamaica, in advocating for police accountability. However, he cautioned against “vilification” and urged that criticism be based on facts rather than rhetoric. 

“Do you believe that we are lacking in oversight and accountability mechanisms?” he asked. “I agree with you, I do not think we are. If one can think of additional accountability instrument or system that would complement those above, I would gladly embrace that too. 

“However, by simply shouting loudly about the need for greater accountability without basis or context is not very useful. Let me hasten to say that this is not a call to silence criticism - far from it. 

“Constructive dialogue, transparency, and accountability are vital to democratic policing. But such dialogue must be grounded in facts, fairness, and a respect for the principles of justice, including the presumption of innocence. Advocacy must not cross the line into vilification.

As Jamaica continues to grapple with crime and policing challenges, the Commissioner’s message was clear: accountability is non-negotiable, but so is respect for the hard work of officers who serve honorably. 

“Let us move forward together,” he concluded, “united in the goal of a safer, more just Jamaica.”